We had six people voting in the final round! And the comments in that entry are now unscreened, so that everyone can see what all was voted for. And to also double check my tallying, lol.
Of the top vote getters, we had five categories that got six votes and four categories that got five votes, so all those first five categories will make the card. I used random.org to fill the final spot from the four categories that got five votes.
These categories all got 6 votes:
Biography/Autobiography
Poetry/Play
Horror
A classic
Never judge a book by its movie
The four categories with five votes were:
True Crime
Blind Book
Out of your comfort zone
Set on or near a holiday
I numbered the categories 1-4 in the above order and then had the randomizer give me a number. Here's the result:

So, "Out of your comfort zone" makes the card!
That makes our final round list look like this:
Biography/Autobiography
Poetry/Play
Horror
A classic
Never judge a book by its movie
Out of your comfort zone
Thank you all so much for voting! I think it was so much fun, though I wish we could have fit all the categories on the card! I'll try to post the new card later tonight or tomorrow!